We investigate query routing techniques in a cluster of databases for a query-dominant environment. The objective is to decrease query response time. Each component of the cluster runs an off-the-shelf DBMS and holds a copy of the whole database. The cluster has a coordinator thatroutes each query to an appropriate component. Consideringqueries of realistic complexity, e.g., TPC-R, this article addresses the following questions: Can routing benefit from caching effects due to previous queries? Since our components are black-boxes, how can we approximate their cache content? How to route a query, given such cache approximations? To answer these questions, we have developed a cache-aware query router that is based on signature approximations of queries. We report on experimental evaluations with the TPC-R benchmark using our PowerDB database cluster prototype. Our main result is that our approach of cache approximation routing is better than state-of-the-art strategies by a factor of tw...