An Empirical Evaluation of Automated Theorem Provers in Software Certification

We describe a system for the automated certification of safety properties of NASA software. The system uses Hoare-style program verification technology to generate proof obligations which are then processed by an automated first-order theorem prover (ATP). We discuss the unique requirements this application places on the ATPs, focusing on automation, proof checking, and usability. For full automation, however, the obligations must be aggressively preprocessed and simplified, and we demonstrate how the individual simplification stages, which are implemented by rewriting, influence the ability of the ATPs to solve the proof tasks. Our results are based on 13 certification experiments that lead to 366 top-level safety obligations and ultimately to more than 25,000 proof tasks which have each been attempted by Vampire, Spass, e-setheo, and Otter. The proofs found by Otter have been proof-checked by IVY. Key words: software certification, automated theorem proving, program synthesis, proof...

• Type: Journal
• Year: 2006
• Where: IJAIT
• Authors: Ewen Denney, Bernd Fischer 0002, Johann Schumann
• Keywords: IJAIT 2006, Proof Checking, Proof Obligations, Proof Tasks