How Risky Is the Random-Oracle Model?

RSA-FDH and many other schemes secure in the Random-Oracle Model (ROM) require a hash function with output size larger than standard sizes. We show that the random-oracle instantiations proposed in the literature for such cases are weaker than a random oracle, including the proposals by Bellare and Rogaway from 1993 and 1996, and the ones implicit in IEEE P1363 and PKCS standards: for instance, there is a practical 230 preimage attack on BR93 for 1024-bit digests. Next, we study the security impact of hash function defects for ROM signatures. As an extreme case, we note that any hash collision would suffice to disclose the master key in the IDbased cryptosystem by Boneh et al. from FOCS ’07, and the secret key in the Rabin-Williams signature for which Bernstein proved tight security at EUROCRYPT ’08. Interestingly, for both of these schemes, a slight modification can prevent these attacks, while preserving the ROM security result. We give evidence that in the case of RSA and Rabi...

• Type: Conference
• Year: 2009
• Where: CRYPTO
• Authors: Gaëtan Leurent, Phong Q. Nguyen
• Keywords: CRYPTO 2009, Cryptology, Hash Function, Hash Function Defects, Practical 230 Preimage