Wiener’s famous attack on RSA with d < N0.25 shows that using a small d for an efficient decryption process makes RSA completely insecure. As an alternative, Wiener proposed to use the Chinese Remainder Theorem in the decryption phase, where dp = d mod (p − 1) and dq = d mod (q − 1) are chosen significantly smaller than p and q. The parameters dp, dq are called private CRT-exponents. Since Wiener’s proposal in 1990, it has been a challenging open question whether there exists a polynomial time attack on small private CRT-exponents. In this paper, we give an affirmative answer to this question, and show that a polynomial time attack exists if dp and dq are smaller than N0.073 .