We show that if SAT does not have small circuits, then there must exist a small number of satisfiable formulas such that every small circuit fails to compute satisfiability correctly on at least one of these formulas. We use this result to show that if PNP[1] = PNP[2], then the polynomial-time hierarchy collapses to Sp 2 ⊆ Σp 2 ∩Πp 2. Even showing that the hierarchy collapsed to Σp 2 remained open prior to this paper.